Here Comes the Fuzz

The CFPB has elected to forgo the rulemaking process and rely on enforcement to hammer businesses in the name of consumer protection.

October 2016, Auto Dealer Today - Feature

by Thomas B. Hudson, Esq. - Also by this author

The title of this piece actually sounds like something Fonzie might have said on “Happy Days,” but what follows is more ominous than any message from the Fonz. Throughout my 43 years of representing creditors who were striving to comply with federal and state compliance obligations, I have heard a steady refrain: “Government,” they say, “just tell us what the rules are, and we will play by them.”

For the most part, governments have responded, proposing regulations, listening to industry and consumer comments, and issuing “bright line” rules dealing with disclosures and other creditor conduct. This made the creditors happy. They might not have been all that crazy about the rules, but the rules applied to all creditors who were similarly situated, so all creditors subject to the rule towed the compliance line.

But then things took an interesting turn. Along came the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. Elizabeth Warren, when setting up the bureau, decided that while more laws and regulations were nifty and all, those laws and regulations were just temporary roadblocks that, she claimed, lawyers would just work their way around.

Nope, she had something a great deal more powerful than black and white regulations. Her new agency had powers granted by the Dodd-Frank Act. Those powers included the prohibition of unfair, deceptive or abusive acts and practices as well as the mandate to enforce federal consumer protection laws, most notably the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, dealing with credit discrimination. All of these are gray, subjective areas where the creditor’s obligation varies depending on the whim and agenda of the enforcer.

Why have bright lines that creditors can actually see — and rules they can actually follow —when you can have an intentionally fuzzy “we know bad acts when we see them” standard in the hands of an aggressive federal regulator? The CFPB’s apparent thinking is that, if the line is fuzzy enough, creditors will be wary of getting too close to it.

That may account for the CFPB’s favorite choice of weapon for doing battle with those nasty creditors. For the most part, its directors have shunned the rulemaking process in favor of enforcement. Rulemaking is, after all, a heavier lift than enforcement, involving, as it does, the burden of actually having to listen to the businesses the CFPB seeks to police.

What is the incentive to go the rulemaking route when you have an unlimited budget and the power to hammer businesses with fines that run to the hundreds of millions of dollars? Based on what we have seen so far, precious few creditors are willing to go toe-to-toe with the CFPB in defense of an enforcement action. The unwillingness to fight is even more apparent when the enforcement target is small, like the one-store Colorado dealership the bureau targeted for a $700,000 hit.

So we’ve gone from a standard developed through the ’80s and early ’90s — “disclose and let the consumer take care of himself” — to the pre-CFPB consumer advocate position that “we need more laws to tame the predatory marketplace” to where we are today: a powerful federal agency that avoids making rules and intentionally blurs the line between legal and illegal conduct.

“We don’t need no stinkin’ laws. We’ve got UDAP, UDAAP and superior moral judgment.”

Yep, here comes the fuzz.

Your Comment

Please note that comments may be moderated. 
Leave this field empty:
Your Name:  
Your Email:  



Jim Ziegler
Stupid Is as Stupid Does

By Jim Ziegler
The Alpha Dawg charts the brief rise and long fall of Johan de Nysschen, the recently departed president of Cadillac and author of the business plan that effectively crowned Lincoln as the new king of American luxury.

They Finally Killed Somebody

By Jim Ziegler
Ziegler believes Uber’s directors should face criminal charges for their role in an Arizona woman’s violent death.

20 Things a GM Must Do Every Week

By Jim Ziegler

All Things Must Pass

By Jim Ziegler

Opening Observations

They Took Cadillac for a Ride

By Tariq Kamal
Hindsight is 20/20, but at least one industry member saw GM’s latest mishap coming a mile away.

Stand Up and Be Counted

By Tariq Kamal
The Dealers’ Choice Awards are the Yelp of vendors and finance sources.

Over the Curb

This Is Us: Dealer Edition

By Jason Heard
Heard knows delegation and outsourcing are the quickest path to a work-life balance.